Does it work for depression?
Karen had been taking Zoloft for three years, but was having trouble with its side effects. Serzone didn't help, and Paxil (40 mg) only seemed to get her right back where she started - grateful to feel human again, but not at all happy with her excess sleep, weight gain, and loss of sexuality. Karen had originally turned to acupuncture for her flu and bronchitis, and found it worked wonders. Now she wondered if acupuncture could help her depression.
Acupuncture originated in China at least 2,000 years ago, and moved to the west in the 1970s as part of a greater awakening that included yoga, meditation, new diets, and other so-called alternative fare. At first, its availability was limited by the scarcity of practitioners, but now there are an estimated 20,000 certified acupuncturists in the US, and one third of these are medical doctors. According to FDA figures from 1993, Americans are making 9 to 12 million visits a year and spending as much as $500 million to have needles strategically placed along the invisible latitude and longitude lines of their skins.
To paraphrase from the National Institutes of Health:
There are more than 2,000 acupuncture points on the body connecting with 12 main and eight secondary pathways called meridians, which conduct energy - chi or qi - between the surface of the body and the internal organs.
According to the NIH:
"Qi regulates spiritual, emotional, mental, and physical balance. Qi is influenced by the opposing forces of yin and yang. According to traditional Chinese medicine, when yin and yang are balanced, they work together with the natural flow of qi to help the body achieve and maintain health. Acupuncture is believed to balance yin and yang, keep the normal flow of energy unblocked, and restore health to the body and mind."
A western interpretation would be that the acupuncture points stimulate the central nervous system, releasing chemicals into the muscles, spinal cord, and brain, promoting the body's natural healing abilities. In the words of the NIH: "Studies have shown that acupuncture may alter brain chemistry by changing the release of neurotransmitters and neurohormones in a good way."
An NIH consensus panel of scientists, researchers, and practitioners in 1997 determined that acupuncture has been clinically proven to be effective against nausea from surgery and chemotherapy, addiction, headaches, menstrual cramps, tennis elbow, fibromyalgia, myofascial pain, osteoarthritis, lower back pain, carpal tunnel syndrome, and asthma, and to assist in stroke rehabilitation. Since then, other studies have looked at pain, ADHD, pregnancy complications, and other diseases and conditions.
In 1996, the FDA approved acupuncture needles for use by licensed practitioners. Needles are either new or sterilized. Relatively few complications have been reported to the FDA, but bad results can happen from improper sterilization of needles and improper treatment. The needles are hair thin and don't cause the kind of pain associated with hollow hypodermic needles.
Fine, but does acupuncture work for depression?
In 1998, the NIH's Office of Alternative Medicine funded a study at the University of Arizona. Working with acupuncturist Rosa Schnyer, John Allen PhD devised a 16-week trial on 34 seriously depressed women. First the two worked up a standard treatment plan that targeted certain "depression points" on the body. Then they devised a dummy treatment calling for needles in nonspecific places. The acupuncturists administering the treatment had no idea whether they were using the real plan or the dummy plan.
Then the subjects were divided into three groups. The first group received the depression-specific acupuncture, the second group got the dummy treatment, and the third group was put on a wait list before being placed on eight weeks of the real thing.
Following the treatment, the depression-specific groups experienced a 43 percent reduction in their symptoms compared with a 22 percent reduction for the dummy group. More than half no longer met the criteria for clinical depression. Only five people dropped out of the study - two who moved away, one who became pregnant, and two who didn't like the needles. The dropout rate was much lower than for studies using medications.
Two advantages of acupuncture, Dr Allen told a seminar at the National Depressive and Manic Depressive Association Conference in Boston, include no language barrier (a factor for patients who have difficulty speaking English), and its low cost compared to conventional treatment.
Something better than low cost was an inducement for Karen. She was able to swap free sessions by giving piano lessons to the acupuncturist's son. On the advice of Dr Chen, her acupuncturist, she did not quit her medication. She began the treatment in May - never going more than once a week - and gradually, she says, she began to recover. "For a few days I felt a little better," she recounts, "then after that I felt bad days. But the better days got better oh so gradually and the bad days less bad."
Karen would lie on a table as Dr Chen put some needles into her ear, arm, and leg - always on the right side (except for a few needles in the other leg). One time he put the needles in similar areas on the left side. He would also point a heat lamp where he left needles in the leg. The needles prick, according to Karen, "just the littlest bit." Then she would remain on the table while Dr Chen left the room for 20 minutes. Finally, Dr Chen would take out the needles and rub some areas of the back and neck.
Karen thinks the first few visits were critical, but her follow-up visits were important, too.
In July, Karen switched to St John's wort before slowly reducing her Paxil in August (she is now down to 10 mg). According to Karen: "I believe both acupuncture and St John's wort have helped me. I think the acupuncture enabled the Saint John's wort to work more effectively. I like the idea of making the body work its best with acupuncture."
She goes on to say: "I have always had to take higher doses of any antidepressant in order to get the best results. Why not get my immune system working better so that I might not need such a high dose or, even better, take St John's wort instead with minimal side effects?"
Dr Chen, says Karen, works on the principle that it's all about helping the body's immune system function in an optimal way so that it keeps the disease in check, resulting in fewer bad symptoms. In Karen's words:
"The body takes time to heal and the acupuncture guides the body to heal itself. Heal from what? I don't think our bodies are working optimally. The body does its best under any circumstances but after years of medications, ravages of depression and stress, excesses in food and drink - sugar, chemicals, smog - acupuncture helps the body recover from these assaults. I have more respect for the working of the body now and the strength of it."
Now, after four and a half months, Karen feels ready to discontinue treatment. As well as easing her depression, she also credits acupuncture for helping her go off sugar. And there is the spiritual side: "I really believe in meditating on God. It spiritualizes the mind which in turn uplifts the mood. Regular meditation is important to me."
If you are thinking of acupuncture for yourself:
Your doctor is a good resource for referrals to licensed acupuncturists. You can also do a search for practitioners in your area at the websites of the American Academy of Medical Acupuncture.
Some 70 to 80 percent of insurers in the US cover acupuncture treatments. Cost per treatment tends to range between $30 and $100. Physician acupuncturists may charge more than non-physician practitioners.
Finally, if you are on medication, don't expect to flush your pills down the toilet after your first visit. This is a matter you will have to work out between you and your doctor or psychiatrist. Fortunately, Karen had an acupuncturist who recognized this. In her words: "I appreciated Dr. Chen's discretion in advising me about the medication. He told me that since he's not a medical doctor he couldn't tell me how much to take or when to quit. He just made me feel comfortable that the acupuncture would still do its job whether I went off the medication or not."
First published in 2000, reviewed in 2008
New studies lend credence to manufacturer's claims, but it's still the wild west out there.
Good brain food?
Too good to be true?
Good for depression?
Knowledge is Necessity
Copyright 2010 John McManamy Contact
You're in the right place. Check out your video guide to McMan's Web.
"Be warned! These musings are addictive." - Kimberly Read, About.com - Bipolar.
"We are who we pretend to be. You can’t go wrong pretending to be JFK or Martin Luther King." Plus more words of wisdom from the newly-anointed family patriarch and elder.
"God has a funny way of treating people He loves most. Just ask Joan of Arc." Plus more stuff I wish I knew when I was two days old.
Schizophrenia in a seven-year-old? Impossible, you say? An eye-opening account from the family.
When a college student with Aspergers is found beaten to death in his dorm room, one can't help but ask the obvious questions.
My normal can be very unpredictable, but at least I know I won't embarrass myself when I feel out-of-it and depressed.
Think you can't be manipulated? The people who signed a petition to ban dihydrogen monoxide (another name for water) didn't think so, either.
This five-part series (and counting) looks at the brief history of diagnostic psychiatry and the man responsible for how we (and our clinicians) view ourselves.
A speedy traverse of my life (in three parts) as the surprise recipient of a major award and why it didn't change my life but sure helped in my recovery.
How a conversation with my daughter triggered a long-suppressed happy memory and offered a healing moment.
How two five-second Zen moments 30 years apart changed my life.
"Nicely produced and edited. I'd love to see more frequent updates." - Sandra Kiume, journalist
The world's oldest wind instrument brings out the playful and spiritual side in me.
We forget. The present is where life is happening - here, right now.
Don't just sit there. Build yourself a tree.
Don't be fooled. There's always a somewhere.
Nature heals. So do our brains.
No koalas were harmed making this movie.
The Buddha was on to something ...
Do people with bipolar cycle in and out of time? Call me bichronic.
In the Spotlight
Lincoln and Darwin were born on the same day, 200 years ago in 1809. These two articles discuss how their actions and ideas apply to you:
His unremitting despair and constant failures steeled his character.
Is there a selective advantage to depression and bipolar?
A Random Sampling
Now that you're familiar with the DSM-IV, forget everything you've read.
A leading anthropologist explains the birds and the bees.
We're depressed way more than we are manic. Now if psychiatry only knew how to treat us.
What is arguably the most effective recovery tool requires a highly disciplined mind.
A smart dopamine med may do wonders for your depression or bipolar or mental acuity. The problem is one doesn't exist.
No, it's not normal kid behavior.
An innovative researcher discovers that patients know best.
Living Well With Depression and Bipolar Disorder by John McManamy (HarperCollins 2006)
"I doubt there is a person in the world who knows these conditions better, inside and out, than John McManamy ... He weaves together the science and the inner experiences of depression and bipolar disorder in a way that is quite rare. This book is full of studies and personal insights, in about equal measure, leavened with the practical conclusions of its even-handed and often humorous author. It breaks new ground." - Nassir Ghaemi MD, Tufts University
Sample Amazon Reviews
"John McManamy has an outstanding ability to describe his and other's experience of having bipolar disorder in all its complexity. He never tries to take the place of the patiet's psychiatrist. He refers his readers to other sources of excellent more detailed clinical information. He tells the human side of the story. He teaches patients how to be better informed consumer's of psychiatric care. He encourages patients to be active participants in their recovery." - Raymond
"This is one of the best books I've read on the subject of Bipolar Disorder or Depression. Filled with real world examples, and crammed with information this book will empower you to take charge of your illness." - Eileen