![]() |
McMan's Depression and Bipolar Web |
| Home Articles Links News Newsletter Books Forum Community Search Donate |
|
Your Depression and Bipolar Disorder Source Knowledge is Necessity Main forum page. Go here.
|
Answers We know that bipolar disorder is a horrific illness. But do you also regard it as a gift that you would not trade to be normal? Feel free to elaborate. Barbara (March 10, 2004): From my
personal experience with BP, I in no way consider this illness a
gift. Perhaps if I were predominantly manic, I would see things
differently. My illness has brought mostly pain to myself and those
close to me over the years. Nicole (March 11, 2004): I suppose I do think of bipolar as a gift, but I can't say that I would or would not "trade" it for being "normal." Through the years and various stages (evolution?) of my illness, I have spent long hours considering how bipolar makes me different from other people. Sometimes I even consider the extremity of my condition and how, in some ways, it makes me different from other people who are bipolar. It seems that everything about being bipolar is a gift and a curse at the same time and I don't know that living that experience is any different from people who are "normal." If "normal" means people who aren't bipolar I am observant that people who don't have bipolar are often faced with other circumstances that I don't have (thankfully) and wouldn't want. My bipolar is such an integrated part of my being that it is impossible for me imagining trading it anymore that I could imagine trading my voice. It has shaped my spirituality and helped me to live, love, and have gratitude. Because I know it will sometimes feel unbearable, I fill my world with reminders that I am responsible for my health and personal growth. I accept responsibility to do the best I can and always strive to learn more and do better. Entertaining any notion of "trading" something that is beyond my control to change is a destructive indulgence that would keep me from growing. I think that would be true even if I were "normal" (although I might not have the insight). I suppose "the grass is always greener" is something I have necessarily left behind. Elizabeth (March 12, 2004): Thank you Nicole for your wisdom. I am going to print out what you wrote and let it remind me what I too have discovered--we each have our own pathways. We can learn from other people's pathways, gain friends and even struggle with foes to glimpse at the world from other viewpoints, but in the end we are on our own pathways. Tina (March 12, 2004): It would be hard to consider Bipolar as a gift as it comes with suicide attempts and suicidal thoughts and planning. I have basically lost many years of my life to this soul sucking illness known as bipolar. At 48, I am beginning to wonder if I will ever get my life back. Between the depressions, the fear of and longing for manias, the side effects from the medications, the expense of the treatment (especially the meds), the stress that this has put on my family and friends, the ever fearful eye watching my daughter for symptoms, the lost sleep and excess of sleep and the constant self monitoring of all my actions that I must do, I would eagerly return this "gift". Also, the stigma that being bipolar brings with it and so much more. If there is someone who thinks of this as a gift and would like to trade, please, choose me. Kendra (March 12, 2004): In some ways I do consider being bipolar a gift. I can not imagine any other way to exist. Being bipolar has made me do some real soul searching. I have spent many years searching hard and deep. I like the person that I am and feel I know the person that I am. If it were not for this disorder, I think I would live life on the surface. Sure the depressions are difficult some times and the manias can be great to a point. (I really like being able to get by on a few hours of sleep). But I try to hold the moods at a distance while grasping tightly to the person that I am. As far as trading it for being normal - well I consider myself normal - a normal person who happens to be bipolar. I wouldn't trade the person I am for the world. Maureen (March 13, 2004): Bipolar disorder in NO GIFT! At 39, I have been to Hell and back more times than I can count. I am now in a "low" state and have been for a while. I see creatures. I only want to be with my pets, not my husband and kids. I fear my children will inherit this disease. My own priest says I am an "unacceptable" candidate to teach CCD because of my illness/medications! I will gladly return this gift if someone will point me in the direction of the Customer Service Counter of life. (Sidebar: Avoid watch the new Fox series "Cracked Up." It is offensive and humiliating to anyone who has ever suffered from mental illness. Peace.) Susan (March 14, 2004): I don't know.
If you had asked me this, a year ago in early 2003, I would have said,
yes, absolutely. That was following a hospitalization that was
frankly, just a few degrees short of Cuckoo's nest, including ECT. LilacsnMay (March 14, 2004): This is definitely not a gift to me. My illness has caused me so much pain and shame. I would like to know what normal feels like. My daughter was just diagnosed bipolar. She's 14. She's been self-harming, taking too many pills, cutting, burning etc. She doesn't sleep, and then she doesn't wake up. She's in danger of repeating the 8th grade because she won't go to school at all. She was an A student, labeled talented and gifted at a young age. Our life is painful, watching her go through this is painful. I try to put on a front for her sake but get so depressed myself watching her. This isn't a gift, it's a curse. Give me life.
Joyce (March 15, 2004): I was diagnosed with manic depression
20 years ago. I'm 43 now, and I feel being bipolar is very much a curse.
I'm a talented person with a master's degree, but I have no partner, no
family, no children, no full-time job, no career, no house, etc, etc. I
have given in to my diagnosis, which is tragic. Corinne (March 16, 2004): I firmly believe that there is no "normal," and I am a Roman Catholic who strives to be grateful for what I get and keep the faith, so I say that I wouldn't trade being bipolar for normalcy. I'm a college freshman and I experienced my first symptoms in 2002, my senior year in high school...I can't say I liked mania (I think it was actually mixed with depression), because it was confusing and my grades stank big time for the first time in my life and I did a few things I'm not proud of, but I enjoy being creative enough to write poetry. (Who knows if it's actually linked to BD, like Dr. Kay R. Jamison hypothesizes?) I've been through some depression since then, even on medication, but overall, I have to say that it's a blessing in disguise because I can sympathize more with others who have mood disorders. In any case, it sure beats other life-threatening illnesses--bipolar comes with highs! Go-Between (March 16, 2004): I wonder if my first manifestation of Bipolar perturbation appeared caused by my strong will to be different from other people. Since I am a teenager, I consider myself different
from other people, and even more: a special boy. I guess many people
have the need for their ego, to consider themselves special. Everybody
wants to be unique. Normality sounds to me like vulgarity -
superfluous human beings. Normal people lead a meaningless and a dull
life. It doesn’t matter if they are the most happy people in the
world. The values are: to have a life history (different from common
people), to be an interesting person and… who would say, the pride of
having suffered a lot and still have survived (not to mention that,
for Christians, this means, as well, to deserve heaven). The point is: I had great moments, but, for sure,
the price to pay is far to high! If the price is a terrible
depression, thanks, I want to be exorcised from this perturbation. Cecilia (March 17, 2004): Is bipolar
disorder a gift? Today I say NO WAY Is it worth getting better after all this time? Catherine (March 18, 2004): I believe
that BP is both a gift and a curse. So many of the previous
contributors have given similar opinions to mine. One lady says that
BP is a part of her, and a teenager says that she feels that normality
is boring. I have to agree with those statements. Another lady said
that she has done a lot of soul searching, which she appreciates. Barbara (March 18, 2004): I'm just
wondering how or why any potentially life-threatening illness could be
considered a gift. Are we gifted in the sense that we are lucky that
we don't have something more serious than bipolar disorder? If I go
to a Diabetes Support Site, would I be likely to find a forum that
asks if anyone would trade their gift of diabetes to be normal? Noria (March 22, 2004): In the ten years I have been undergoing treatment I have thought a lot about what being bipolar really means in my life and my personality. I've never seen proof that if the illness was somehow removed, personality and creativity would remain intact. Being a creative professional, I wouldn't take the chance that bipolarism was somehow the lynch pin of my being. Irish Eyes (March 23, 2004): I believe Bipolar disorder is simply a label, a word to describe certain individuals who society deems as NOT NORMAL according to their standards. Words, simply words, gift-curse depends on how you look at it. If you want it to be a curse then it certainly can be, if you think of it as a gift then it certainly will be. Nothing is either good or bad (gift or curse) it is thinking that makes it so. Cecilia, life begins at 40 so they say. I think we can choose to believe we are normal or abnormal, can't we just be. Can't we simply live one moment at a time and stop worrying about the disease that the DRs say we have, simply believing we have a disease makes us not feel good to begin with. Personally, I would rather be well. The Psychiatrist said that it is all a thinking error, so we need to start thinking differently. If we believe we are ill, then surely we WILL BE ILL, if we think we are healthy then we will be. Cognitive behavioural therapy is very interesting, as a man thinks so he becomes, so start thinking healthy thoughts and you will start to feel healthy - easy as pie. What you think is what you feel, so ask yourself what were you thinking, if you keep thinking about the illness all the time, what are you going to feel ILL. Mind over matter, simply believe that you are well, it's that simple. It's what you believe, if you believe the pills help then they do, if you believe you have side effects then you will have them. Change your thoughts and you change your world. Now, if I could take all this advise and I will. Thanks for letting me vent. God Bless you all. much love Go-Between (March 23, 2004): For those who wouldn't trade bipolar perturbation, how do you handle the idea of the risk of having a bipolar kid and imagine that he/she will pass through what you have passed. All that suffering. Nicole (March 25, 2004): (In response
to Go-Between: For those who wouldn't trade bipolar perturbation, how
do you handle the idea of the risk of having a bipolar kid and imagine
that he/she will pass through what you have passed. All that
suffering.) JJH (March 28, 2004): I myself am a Rapid Cycler II, which I understand to mean that my manias are mostly composed of anxiety and panic attacks. I do not experience the glorious or creative highs that other manics glowingly describe. Our maid of honor killed herself with this illness, and I have been close on many occasions. Maybe the Doctors need to further break down the classifications of this illness, because the Bi-Polar that I have and have experienced in my family members (~75% paternal side occurrences), including my daughter since she was 5, (Yes, children can have it) is a hideous, evil, tormenting illness that couldn't be much worse than anything in Dante's inferno. Maybe we need to understand that there are different classifications of this illness, but I can tell you that although I will never take my own life, I many times long for a place where I can be free from this vile disgusting illness. If it is a gift, than I must thank Satan, because only he could be so gracious and generous. Maree (March 31, 2004): After struggling with life for 28years 3 hospitalizations and many breakdowns I was finally diagnosed with BP the year before last. It was of great relief to me that it wasn't all in my head, that I truly was different to the people around me. As hard as it can be to sometimes carry the label that goes with having a mental illness, it reminds me that "hey Im doing ok". There are always people out there worse off then me. I wouldn't call having BP a gift, however I wouldn't trade it either. The experiences I have had in my life, good and bad have made me the caring compassionate person that I am today. I have good med's now and life is good. I have been given this illness to help others in life. I have almost completed my degree in counseling, and will use my illness to work with others with similar life difficulties. It can be hard when your down as far as you feel you can go, but things will get better. I never thought I would be so happy within myself - (ever). To those of you who are in that place, hang in there, life is worth living. Psychotic Feature (April 6, 2004): Although it takes me on a wild trip, I wouldn't change it. Colors are brighter and more vivid, my mind can do amazing things (that are recognized by others as being pretty darn good). I also understand the deep pain that others can feel. It is this very disease that brought me to a psychology degree for the specific purpose of helping others. I would not be here were it not for this disease. God gave me a gift of helping and healing and I would not have recognized it otherwise. Shelly (April 7, 2004): I go day by day, fighting the angry feelings and depression I get from being bipolar, and I just cant see how anybody can look at this horrible disease as a gift, I realize that there are worse things out there, but to dream of having 1 good day little lone a good week, w/o having to feel anxiety , or wanting to give up, or confusion, short memory, loss of concentration, and no patience with family, I dream and pray to feel peace and happiness every day, And fight against my illness daily. Yes i have good moments but its rarely, and i thank god for my wonderful kids for being by my side and understanding, for i cant always be there for them. I know im very lucky for having them. So on that part im very happy! If it wasn't for my bipolar I could say my life is perfect!!! MB (April 7, 2004): In high school, I was an excellent student at a difficult college prep school. But when all my friends and I went to college, I failed miserably (not knowing I was BP) and they all graduated and got great jobs. I was lost. Years later I am still in a menial job.. taking classes one by one. But though I may not look like a success to everybody else-- I am in love my life and am proud of myself. I have learned many ways to make this so. For one, I never compare myself to people w/out BP.
This is the path chosen for me and as long as I do my job (dealing
with BP) and improve my life to the best of my abilities, then I am a
success! 2nd: I surround myself with many good "healthy" people. I
seperate myself from getting too emotionally connected to people with
continuous emotional problems, b/c the emotional energy I expend in
helping them may be the last bit I have left to pull myself out of the
dreggs. 3rd: I surround myself with hobbies, pets, and people that
make me smile and laugh. When you're really down and out, there is
nothing like an wet, unjudgemental puppy nose nudging you to make you
feel loved. 4th: I am careful to cultivate good, strong relationships
b/c someone in my condition can not afford to burn bridges or be a
loner. Though there will always be the rough times, I feel it is a gift b/c God would not have chosen to give it to me if I couldn't handle it. Cheryl (April 11, 2004): I hate being Bipolar and I love it. I hate it because my family wishes I weren't. because they aren't. and I hate it because the "world" wishes I weren't...because it isn't. I love it, because I see what no one else sees. The world is a different place to me, than it is to "them". As a Bipolar, I am artistic, creative, articulate, brilliant, comedic, cynical, energetic and yet I can't hold a job for a minute. It's a shame, too, because I am a very talented Photographer (that's what I've been told anyway). Does it bother me, that I can't hold a job, though? No. Not right now, anyway. It just bother's everyone else, and being the cynic that I am, I find a wealth of joy in that...today anyway. The thing I don't like about being Bipolar is the inability to remember much of anything. My childhood, (though I know that I was molested as a young girl) is, to me, nonexistent. I suppose I could sit around and worry over "this and that" of being "wronged" as a child and so forth and I do, on a typically bad day...but it's far and few in between, because on bad days, I sleep. I do tend to muse over memories that are faint, wondering if what I remember and what actually happened are one in the same. Another is the "con's" of being Bipolar is a bad memory. When I relay a story to my husband or family...well *sigh*...9 times, out of 10, the story has been completely changed. It's not intentional, of course. I try to relay things that are are of import or humor with precise and correct detail...but somehow, it comes out completely contorted and distorted and I'm the only one who appreciates it. A Bipolar "Pro"? (as opposed to a "con") My husband is my anchor. Every BiPolar individual should have an anchor! He is my confidante, my cheering squad, my minister, my HERO! He's also my reality check, my memory bank, the keeper of the checks and money (thank God!) and my firing squad (only when humorously needed). Anonymous (April 13, 2004): Depending on which phase we are in the answer would be different. For my answer.. I would say yes. First of all i do not know what it means to be normal. so how do i know I want it? I would not be who I am today. I would not have experienced my adventures due to my highs and life lessons from my lows. The people who are in my life, who have stuck by me despite everything, are a special group. They can handle me, which means they are strong. Would I have strong people in my life without the disease? There are times when I want to do die. I choose not to kill myself for I have learned how valuable my life is. Those who are suicidal without this disorder... do they have the same advantage? Their are so many things that I regret in my life, even obsess over. But without those moments, would I have lost out on the right choices? When times are hard i would beg to be normal... when I am high... I wouldn't care.... When i am normal (for me) I wouldn't change a thing. Evie (April 14, 2004): I agree with what others are saying in the respect that I have no idea what it is like to be normal. Like others, I have had this illness since I was a kid. I finally had a real nervous breakdown when I was a senior in highschool. On my good days, I am so thankful to just feel good! On my other days, I would not consider this illness a gift. I know that God allowed it in my life, so I trust Him that He will carry me through how hard it is. I thankfully have an awesome supportive husband who is a rock in my life. What I really, really hate about this illness is being a rapid cycler! Also, I know who I want to be...a kind, gentle, loving person...and then I act like my illness...angry and irritable. It is so hard to go from being depressed to being manic. Like another person said, I hate having to watch myself...am I getting up in people's faces, talking too loud, talking too fast...you know what I mean. I also hate having plans and then feeling so out of it in the depressed realm that I really just want to stay at home and stare at a wall. So how do you call people and say, "hey, we'd rather not come so Evie can stay home and stare at the wall." I grieve with all of you who talked about memory loss. Isn't it awful to not be able to remember stuff anymore. The illness and the meds just rob you of so much. However, despite my illness I have been able to have a life that I feel good about. I work with teenagers because my husband is a youth pastor. They don't even know I struggle. Somehow God just keeps me together so I can handle all of their needs as they come up. So, while it is not a gift, I am not going to let it get the best of me!! Post your opinion here. |
John McManamy Newsletter Your online source for issues that matter to you. For free samples, email me and put "Sample" in the heading and your email address in the body. Find out more. Bookstore Shop for depression and bipolar books online here.
|