Recovery

God Power

This just in - religion and spirituality work.

by John McManamy

Jesus asked him, ‘What is your name?’ ‘Legion,’ he replied. This was because so many devils had taken possession of him. ... the devils came out of the man and went in to the pigs, and the herd rushed over the edge of the lake and were drowned. ... The spectators told them how the mad-man had been cured." (Luke 8.30 - 37.)

Jesus is savior to many, and known as a healer to all, many who pray to him or a veritable pantheon of saints for release from their physical and mental afflictions. The power of spiritual healing is not confined to Christianity. The great Jewish prophet Elijah was also a healer, and the faith has a long tradition of nabi’im who have performed miracles.

One of the best-known Buddhist parables involves the Buddha refusing to use his power to heal in order to teach the lesson of acceptance, though the Mahayana branch of the faith as practiced by the Tibetans parallels Catholicism in its belief in the healing power of holy objects and petitions to saints. The mind-body movement of Deepak Chopra is grounded in Hindu ayurvedic medicine, and the New Age phenomenon is based in large part on the shamanic traditions of a whole range of cultures.

Spiritual and Religious Practice

Some three hundred years ago, the Age of Faith gave way to the Age of Reason. Out the window went the power of prayer, to be replaced by the belief that the key to physical and mental recovery resided in the hands of medical science - amongst learned men and women, anyway. The unwashed still persisted with their silly superstitions.

Now science has done a complete 180. To date, there have been about 1,200 studies on the healing power of faith and the health effects of spirituality, according to Dr Harold Koenig, founder of the Center for the Study of Religion/Spirituality at Duke University. Five studies he has been involved in include:

* A 1998 study of nearly 4,000 people aged 65 years and older which found the risk of diastolic hypertension 40 percent lower among people who attended religious services at least once a week and prayed or studied the Bible at least daily.
* A 1997 study of more than 1,700 older adults from North Carolina which found that persons who attended church at least once a week were only half as likely as non-attenders to have elevated levels of interleukin-6, an immune system protein involved in a wide variety of age-related diseases.
* A 1998 study of 87 depressed older adults which found those who recovered from depression the fastest corresponded to the extent of their religious belief.
* A study of 542 patients aged 60 or older admitted to Duke University Medical Center which found those who attended religious services weekly or more reduced hospital stays by more than half. People with no religious affiliation spent an average of 25 days in the hospital compared to 11 days for patients affiliated with some religious denomination. Patients who attended religious services weekly or more also were 43 percent less likely to have been hospitalized in the previous year.
* A 2002 study of 116 depressed geriatric patients who were given standard medications treatment over 12 weeks. The recovered patients in the study reported "significantly more frequent public and private religious practices, greater positive religious coping, and less negative religious coping" than those who remained depressed.

The National Institute of Health Care Research, which listed four of these Duke studies, also included:

* A 1995 study of 232 patients at Dartmouth Medical School which found that elderly heart patients were 14 times less likely to die following surgery if they found strength and comfort in their religious faith and remained socially involved.
* A landmark University of California at Berkeley study that followed 5,286 people from Alameda County, California over 28 years, which found those who attended religious services weekly or more were 25 percent less likely to die than infrequent attenders.
* A 1998 study of 2,025 senior citizens in Marin County, California which found attending worship services on a regular basis was an important factor in predicting longevity.
* A 1999 study tracking more than 21,000 US adults which found attending religious services more than once a week can expand one’s life up to seven years and added a potential 14 more years to the life span of African Americans.

In 2001, Dr Koenig, along with fellow Duke scientist, David Larson MD, MSPH, and Michael McCullough PhD of Southern Methodist University, published "Handbook for Religion and Health" (Oxford University Press). In preparing the book for publication, the authors reviewed more than 100 studies on the relationship of religion to depression. Two-thirds of those studies found religious persons have less depression than those who are non-religious, and if they become depressed, they recover more quickly.

A review of 12 studies by Dr Larson et al published in the Journal of Psychology and Theology in 1991 found a positive relationship between religious commitment and lower suicide rates. A study by Nisbet et al published in the Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorders in 2000 found that adults 50 years or older who never participated in religious activities were four times more likely than religious people in their age group to commit suicide, replicating the results of a 1972 study.

Skeptics cite the placebo effect as a probable cause of the benefits of spiritual belief, together with the fact that religious communities offer the kind of support networks that reduce stress and ease mental anguish. Additionally, those who attend religious services have better health habits, such as drinking and smoking less. Finally, religions encourage marriage, which is a reliable predictor of longer life.

But the true cause of the healing effect hardly matters. In an interview in the Winter 2002 issue of Health and Spirituality Connection, Dr Koenig explained that religion gives people hope and optimism and helps them better overcome a negative life experience. Some religious people may think God is punishing them or become overburdened with guilt, but religion can also relieve guilt and grant forgiveness.

An Interesting Little Sidebar

A 2001Italian study published in the British Medical Journal found that reciting the Ave Maria or chanting a Hindu mantra six times a minute "enhances and synchronizes ... cardiovascular rhythms" by slowing respiration to the same timing as circulatory rhythms, creating a feeling of well being. The Ave Maria is recited 50 times in the rosary. The priest recites "Ave Maria, gratia plena, Dominus tecum, benedicta tui mulieribus et benedictus fructus ventris tui Jesus", and the congregation answers: "Sancta Maria, Mater Dei, ora pro nobis peccatoribus, nunc et in hora mortis nostrae, Amen." Both the Ave Maria and the Hindu mantra, "Om mani padme om," each take about ten seconds to recite.

According to the study’s authors: "The rosary was introduced to Europe by the crusaders, who took it from the Arabs, who in turn took it from Tibetan monks and the yoga masters of India. This supports the hypothesis that the similar characteristics and effects of these mantras and of the rosary may not be a simple coincidence."

Conclusion

Even though no one is certain how spiritual practice aids in recovery, it is apparent that a number of processes in the body are being enlisted in the cause, from the brain’s relaxation response to the release of hormones to the strengthening of the body’s immune system. A Yankelovich survey found 94 percent of HMO professionals and 99 percent of family physicians agreeing that personal prayer can enhance medical treatment. More surprising, 75 percent of the family physicians believed that prayers of others could promote a patient's recovery.

A Gallup Poll found 95 percent of those in the US believe in God or a Universal Spirit. In addition, 85 percent of Americans consider religion "very important" or "fairly important" in their lives. A 1997 survey found 80 percent of psychiatric inpatients consider themselves spiritual or religious persons, with 68 percent relying on religion as a source of strength "a great deal."

Of 125 medical schools in the US, most now require spirituality and healing classes for graduation or as a component of a required class. In 1994, only four medical schools offered these classes. This is a far cry from the legacy of Freud, who described religious beliefs as a mass delusion and the Catholic faith as the enemy. As recently as the 1990s, the DSM-III-R used religious behavior in 23 percent of its examples of psychopathology

According to Dr Herbert Benson, president of the Mind/Body Medical Institute of Boston's Deaconess Hospital and Harvard Medical School, cited in a 1996 Time cover story: "Anywhere from 60 percent to 90 percent of visits to doctors are in the mind-body, stress-related realm."

In his book Timeless Healing (Scribner), Benson contends that humans are actually engineered for religious faith: "Our genetic blueprint has made believing in an Infinite Absolute part of our nature."

Needless to say, if you don’t believe in a higher power or belong to a religious group, you may get depressed simply reading this. It’s always difficult, after all, being left out. Be assured, the benefits of spiritual practice can still apply to you. You simply have to find a non-religious way of going about it. Meditation and yoga, for instance, is very atheist-friendly. It may be as simple as closing your eyes, and chanting, "Peace."

And many religious works and services can evoke a strong inner response without the necessity of having to believe.

As well as attending services, a good daily practice is recommended. This can range from a five-minute Bible reading to an hour-long meditation. It is helpful to abide by a strict schedule and set aside a certain part of the house, lighting candles or incense, if necessary, to set the mood. If you have bipolar, bear in mind you are capable of inspiring yourself into a state of mania, and that retreats or seminars that have an all-night component should raise the yellow caution flag with you.

Finally, remember that spiritual practice should be regarded as a complement rather than a substitute for proper medical care. A 1998 University of California study reviewed the medical records of 172 children who died after their parents relied on faith healing instead of standard medicine. The majority of these children would have survived if they had received normal medical care.

Updated Feb 11, 2008

Comment to this article

You May Also Find This of Interest

Biblemania

A look at the Bible's themes of madness, dysfunction, and reconciliation.


Knowledge is Necessity

Home Mood Behavior Treatment Recovery Science Issues Famous Stories Populations Resources Blog About

Copyright 2009 John McManamy Contact


 

You're in the right place. Check out your video guide to McMan's Web.

Check It Out

Knowledge is Necessity Blog

"Be warned! These musings are addictive." - Kimberly Read, About.com - Bipolar.

Featured Blogs

Advice to a New Grandson

"We are who we pretend to be. You can’t go wrong pretending to be JFK or Martin Luther King." Plus more words of wisdom from the newly-anointed family patriarch and elder.

Advice to a New Grandson - Part II

"God has a funny way of treating people He loves most. Just ask Joan of Arc." Plus more stuff I wish I knew when I was two days old.

Latest Blogs

Listening to Mental Illness

Schizophrenia in a seven-year-old? Impossible, you say? An eye-opening account from the family.

Scott Gregory Hawkins - Who Will Speak Out?

When a college student with Aspergers is found beaten to death in his dorm room, one can't help but ask the obvious questions.

My Zombie State is Other People's Normal

My normal can be very unpredictable, but at least I know I won't embarrass myself when I feel out-of-it and depressed.

This Just In: We Are Sheep

Think you can't be manipulated? The people who signed a petition to ban dihydrogen monoxide (another name for water) didn't think so, either.

Robert Spitzer and the DSM - Part V

This five-part series (and counting) looks at the brief history of diagnostic psychiatry and the man responsible for how we (and our clinicians) view ourselves.

My Life as an International Awardee - Conclusion

A speedy traverse of my life (in three parts) as the surprise recipient of a major award and why it didn't change my life but sure helped in my recovery.

The Gift

How a conversation with my daughter triggered a long-suppressed happy memory and offered a healing moment.

Coming to Terms

How two five-second Zen moments 30 years apart changed my life.

 

Recent Videos

"Nicely produced and edited. I'd love to see more frequent updates." - Sandra Kiume, journalist

My Didgeridoo Experience

The world's oldest wind instrument brings out the playful and spiritual side in me.

Mindfulness - Living in the Present

We forget. The present is where life is happening - here, right now.

Gonna Build Me a Tree

Don't just sit there. Build yourself a tree.

Road to Nowhere

Don't be fooled. There's always a somewhere.

Healing

Nature heals. So do our brains.

Managing Anger

No koalas were harmed making this movie.

Mindfulness: The Ultimate Mood Stabilizer

The Buddha was on to something ...

The Bipolar Time Warp

Do people with bipolar cycle in and out of time? Call me bichronic.

More Videos ...

In the Spotlight

Lincoln and Darwin were born on the same day, 200 years ago in 1809. These two articles discuss how their actions and ideas apply to you:

Lincoln and His Depressions

His unremitting despair and constant failures steeled his character.

The Darwinian Challenge

Is there a selective advantage to depression and bipolar?

A Random Sampling

The Mood Spectrum

Now that you're familiar with the DSM-IV, forget everything you've read.

The Brain in Love and Lust

A leading anthropologist explains the birds and the bees.

Treating Bipolar Depression

We're depressed way more than we are manic. Now if psychiatry only knew how to treat us.

Mindfulness - The Ultimate Mood Stabilizer

What is arguably the most effective recovery tool requires a highly disciplined mind.

Dopamine - Serotonin's Secret Weapon

A smart dopamine med may do wonders for your depression or bipolar or mental acuity. The problem is one doesn't exist.

The Bipolar Child

No, it's not normal kid behavior.

Staying Well

An innovative researcher discovers that patients know best.

Living Well With Depression and Bipolar Disorder by John McManamy (HarperCollins 2006)

"I doubt there is a person in the world who knows these conditions better, inside and out, than John McManamy ... He weaves together the science and the inner experiences of depression and bipolar disorder in a way that is quite rare. This book is full of studies and personal insights, in about equal measure, leavened with the practical conclusions of its even-handed and often humorous author. It breaks new ground." - Nassir Ghaemi MD, Tufts University

Sample Amazon Reviews

"John McManamy has an outstanding ability to describe his and other's experience of having bipolar disorder in all its complexity. He never tries to take the place of the patiet's psychiatrist. He refers his readers to other sources of excellent more detailed clinical information. He tells the human side of the story. He teaches patients how to be better informed consumer's of psychiatric care. He encourages patients to be active participants in their recovery." - Raymond


"This is one of the best books I've read on the subject of Bipolar Disorder or Depression. Filled with real world examples, and crammed with information this book will empower you to take charge of your illness." - Eileen

Purchase from Amazon

Find out more

 

"Knowledge is Necessity" blog.

"McMan's Report" newsletter.

Tell A Friend!